ELEPHANTS RESOURCE / 5 MIN READ
An original Elephants in Main Street perspective, retained in the on-site knowledge bank for practical use.
An article for coaches and leaders
Someone can leave a coaching session with greater confidence, a clearer sense of purpose and a well-considered development plan — and still return to a workplace where nobody gives them the chance to progress.
That is not necessarily a failure of coaching. It may be a failure to connect development with opportunity.
René Carayol’s article on mentoring and sponsorship raises an important challenge: helping someone improve and actively advocating for their advancement are different contributions. Both matter. For coaches and leaders, the question is how to ensure that one does not become a substitute for the other.
Understand which role you are playing
For practical purposes, it helps to distinguish three roles. A coach helps someone examine their thinking, make choices and take responsibility for action. A mentor shares experience and guidance. A sponsor uses their influence to advocate for someone’s access to opportunities. Gallup and Catalyst make the same distinction between mentoring as guidance and sponsorship as active advocacy.
These roles can overlap, but they should not be confused.
A leader might coach a colleague through a difficult decision, offer mentoring drawn from experience, then recommend that person for a stretch assignment. Each contribution serves a different need. The important thing is to be clear about the role being played and the expectations attached to it.
An external coach may have no authority over appointments or promotions. That does not diminish their value. It does mean that development work needs to take account of how opportunities are allocated, rather than assuming that improved performance will automatically be recognised.
For coaches: explore the opportunity, not just the individual
When a client says, “I am ready for the next step, but nothing is happening,” it is tempting to focus immediately on confidence, communication or personal branding.
Those may be relevant. They may not be the main obstacle.
Perhaps the client’s achievements are poorly understood outside their immediate team. Perhaps the criteria for advancement are unclear. Perhaps they have never been offered an assignment that would demonstrate their readiness. Or perhaps the organisation’s selection process is inconsistent.
Useful coaching questions therefore extend beyond “What do you need to improve?” Ask: “How are people selected for the opportunities you want?” “Who has seen evidence of your contribution?” And, crucially, “Is this the progression you actually want?”
The aim is not to teach clients to cultivate powerful people for favours. It is to help them understand their environment, communicate their contribution honestly and make informed decisions about where to invest their effort.
Sometimes the next step will be a development action. Sometimes it will be a conversation about selection criteria. Sometimes it will be recognising that a different organisation offers a better fit.
For leaders: make support tangible
Encouragement is valuable, but it does not allocate responsibility, provide exposure or change a selection decision.
Consider an illustrative example. A capable operations manager repeatedly delivers complex improvements. Their leader praises them privately and encourages them to think more strategically. Yet whenever a cross-functional initiative is discussed, someone more familiar to the executive team is selected.
The manager receives positive feedback without gaining the experience that would strengthen their case for advancement.
A sponsoring leader could respond differently. They could recommend the manager for a defined workstream, explain the evidence supporting that recommendation and agree the support needed for success. They could then ensure the manager presents the results and receives credit for the contribution.
That is more useful than a vague promise to “keep an eye out”. It is also more responsible than pushing someone into a role without preparation.
Sponsorship should make a fair, evidence-based case for opportunity. It should not guarantee promotion, bypass proper selection or protect someone from accountability.
Look beyond the people who already have access
Leaders should examine whom they notice and why.
The colleague who speaks confidently in meetings may be highly capable. So may the colleague whose work is less visible, whose responsibilities limit informal networking, or who has not learned the organisation’s unwritten rules.
Familiarity is not evidence of readiness.
Catalyst identifies sponsorship as an important way to address gaps in access to advancement. Gallup also recommends purposeful programmes with clear expectations and monitored outcomes.
A practical starting point is to review who receives stretch assignments, senior exposure and recommendations. Ask whether the criteria are explicit and whether comparable contributions receive comparable consideration.
Do not wait for someone to ask for sponsorship before considering their potential. Equally, do not assume that they want the career path you would choose for them. Discuss their ambitions before advocating on their behalf.
Keep trust and boundaries intact
Coaches and leaders can strengthen development by working towards compatible goals, but that does not entitle a leader to the contents of a confidential coaching conversation.
Where coaching is involved, agree what may be shared, with whom and for what purpose. A client might choose to communicate a development goal or request a particular assignment. They should not have to surrender private reflections to gain support.
Leaders who both coach and assess employees should also be explicit about that dual role. Someone needs to know whether a conversation is exploratory, advisory or part of a formal performance decision.
Clear boundaries make honest development conversations more possible. They also help prevent sponsorship from becoming an expectation of personal loyalty.
Measure whether development leads somewhere
Attendance at coaching sessions and positive feedback on mentoring programmes tell only part of the story.
Look also at what happens afterwards. Are people taking on meaningful responsibilities? Are they gaining relevant experience? Do they understand how progression decisions are made? Is access widening beyond the usual candidates?
Promotion is one outcome, but it is not the only legitimate one. A successful next step might be a specialist role, a lateral move or greater responsibility without becoming a people manager.
The essential question is whether development is helping people pursue opportunities that fit their capabilities and ambitions.
For coaches, the challenge is to help clients understand both themselves and the system around them. For leaders, it is to use authority responsibly so that capable people receive a fair chance to demonstrate what they can do.
At your next development conversation, ask not only, “What does this person need to learn?” Ask also, “What opportunity would allow them to apply that learning — and what can I responsibly do to make it available?”
A USEFUL NEXT STEP
What would this change in the way your people lead, decide or work together?
Bring the live question to the herd. We can help connect the thinking to your culture, leadership and strategic intent.
Start a conversation ↗
